Patidar support for Congress: Hardik Patel. Gujarat Patidar leader Hardik Patel has extended his support to the Congress after the party agreed to give reservation to the community. Patel said the Congress promised to bring in a bill on reservation for Patidars when and if they come to power in Gujarat. But he wanted that the Congress will have to put the reservation formula with details in their election manifesto. Hardik’s volte face came hours after the Patidar leader had said he had not sought tickets for the Assembly elections, and that the Congress was no different from the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party.
Patidar leader Hardik Patel on Wednesday announced his support to the Congress in the Gujarat Assembly election after it reached an understanding with him by promising job quotas to the agitating Patel community if it comes to power.
Hardik Patel made the much-awaited announcement on behalf of the Patidar Anamat Andolan Samiti (PAAS) at a crowded press conference in Ahmedabad and said the PAAS was formally accepting the “workable formula” advanced by the Congress.
“The Congress has accepted our demand for reservations with a formula that provides for benefits equivalent to OBCs constitutionally, without disturbing the present 49 per cent quota for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and OBCs,” Patel said.
“We are accepting the formula given to us by the Congress party.”
Neither Patel nor Congress gave out details of the understanding reached on the reservation formula. Senior Congress leader and former Union minister Kapil Sibal, who had held discussions with Patel and other PAAS leades, said Hardik Patel would reveal the details of the formula at an appropriate time.
Sibal merely said that his party’s suggestions on providing quotas to Patidars in poll-bound Gujarat was “as per the Constitution”.
But Finance Minister and BJP leader Arun Jaitley mocked the agreement calling it an exercise at “deception of each other”.
“From the statements that I have seen so far, the Congress-Hardik club is one of mutual deception. The law of the land is very clear and that is laid down by the Supreme Court and only last week in the Rajasthan case it has been reaffirmed that the 50 per cent cap cannot be breached.
“They can continue to mutually deceive each other and deceive the public by saying that we will devise a methodology by breaching the cap. Legally and constitutionally it is not possible as the law stands today,” he said.
Gujarat Deputy Chief Minister Nitin Patel lashed out at Hardik Patel for accepting the Congress formula on job quotas and supporting it in the Assembly polls, calling him a “fool”.
“Fools have given a formula and fools have accepted it,” a fuming Nitin Patel said. “I have not seen a more foolish person than Hardik. He is young boy. He may have got some love from the community but they are going to perish soon.”
Flanked by other leaders of the PAAS, which has been campaigning for job quotas for the Patels, Hardik Patel brushed aside allegations by the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) that he was “a Congress agent”.
“The Congress has accepted our demands though it is in opposition and has promised to even include it in its manifesto,” he said.
“In this situation, when the BJP tortured our youth and slapped false cases, including those of sedition, there is nothing wrong in supporting the Congress.
“Let the BJP call me a Congress agent. I am nobody’s agent, except that of the people. The BJP doesn’t have a land title to Gujarat, six crore people own the state.”
Hardik Patel said the Congress had said that if it won the Gujarat elections, it would pass a proposal for reservations under Articles 31-C and 46 of the Constitution.
He insisted that the Constitution nowhere said more than 50 per cent reservations could not be given. “The Supreme Court has only given suggestions on this. There is neither any law nor provision in the Constitution.”
He said a new Gujarat government would talk to all the stakeholders and set up a separate Commission.
“The Congress has promised that a survey would be carried out within Patel or any other forward community as per the provisions of the OBC Commission and on this basis parameters of economic, social, educational or employment would be used to extend reservation benefits to Patels and other forward communities,” Patel said.
He claimed that since 1994, many states, including Gujarat, had given quotas beyond 50 per cent and in states as Tamil Nadu and Karnataka such reservation had been in existence for 15 to 17 years.
Patel said he was accepting the formula not just on behalf of PAAS but after speaking to several community leaders and key religious organisations – Khodaldham and Umiyadham. However, heads of both these bodies denied having received any details about the Congress formula.
He claimed that since 1994, many states, including Gujarat, had given quotas beyond 50 per cent and in states as Tamil Nadu and Karnataka such reservation had been in existence for 15 to 17 years.
Patel said he was accepting the formula not just on behalf of PAAS but after speaking to several community leaders and key religious organisations – Khodaldham and Umiyadham.
However, heads of both these bodies denied having received any details about the Congress formula.
“I expect we should receive the formula sometime today and then we will get it verified by senior Constitutional lawyers and then announce our stance,” Paresh Gajera, head of Khodaldham Trust, said.
“We are an apolitical organization. We, however, believe that reservations must be given to Patels as more than 60 per cent of Patels are living in poverty.”
The Chairperson of Unjha Umiyadham Trust, Vikram Patel, however alleged that Hardik Patel was lying.
Talking to reporters after Patel announced that Congress has accepted the community’s demand for quotas in jobs and college admissions if voted to power, he said the party had given its suggestions after a lot of thinking.
“As far as formula is concerned, he (Hardik Patel) will himself speak about it… how will we move ahead in the coming days. Whatever suggestions we have given are after a lot of thinking and as per the Constitution,” Sibal said.
Sibal said that the Congress was happy that a new front would fight against the Bharatiya Janata Party in the Gujarat assembly polls on December 9 and 14.
“We need to struggle, win polls and implement whatever promises we have made. We are not among those who make big promises and do nothing and present wrong statistics in order to win the elections,” he said.
Questioning the work done by BJP governments in the state over the past 22 years for the Patidars, he said they had only filed sedition cases against the PAAS leader.
“I want to know what have they done for the Patidar community. What have they done other than filing sedition cases. The BJP has betrayed their trust.
“I want to ask the BJP… who arrested Hardik in a sedition case? They (the BJP) have nothing to do with the Constitution. The lesser the BJP talk about constitution, the better it is,” he said.
Arun Jaitley mocked the understanding because quotas cannot exceed the constitutional ceiling of 50 per cent.
“From the statements that I have seen so far, the Congress-Hardik club is one of mutual deception. The law of the land is very clear and that is laid down by the Supreme Court and only last week in the Rajansthan case it has been reaffirmed that the 50 per cent cap cannot be breached.
On the claim by Patel that the proposed reservation law could be put in the 9th Schedule under Article 31 (C) of the Constitution Jaitley said even that entry into 9th Schedule is subject to judicial review which is subject to challenge on the basic structure.
“Therefore, in election only those promises can be made to each other and to public which are capable of implementation. Otherwise you deceive yourself and you deceive your constituents,” he said.
On the “Chaiwala” jibe by Gujarat Youth Congress against Prime Minister, Jaitley said: “This debate has taken place in the past also. Now, in democracy there is no place for big family or small family. This is the strength of the Indian democracy that anybody from a humble beginning can emerge and defeat the mightiest. We have seen this happening in this country.” (IANS)